AI is generating a 'human premium' for art created by humans. But will it last?

AI is generating a 'human premium' for art created by humans. But will it last?
Summary
A DJ night in Cornwall illustrates the unique human experience behind live music events.
44% of tracks on Deezer are AI-generated, yet many listeners prefer human-created art.
Increased reliance on algorithms may diminish the depth of our cultural experiences over time.

Share

Bookmark

Newsletter

A few weeks ago, I played at Rave Machine, a vibrant DJ night held in a repurposed bank building in Falmouth, Cornwall. The atmosphere was electric, filled with high-energy music and a passionate crowd—all essential ingredients for a memorable night of dancing.

Every aspect of the evening—from the audience and performers to the staff and the commute home—came together to create a unique, unrepeatable experience intrinsically tied to human connection.

Interestingly, while the night felt wholly organic, technology has already altered the DJ landscape significantly. In the 1990s, DJs relied solely on vinyl records, turntables, and a mixer to create their sets. Today, technology offers various tools, including software that can automatically sync beats. Platforms like Apple Music and Spotify have even integrated AI features for mixing tracks, although I personally prefer to keep things manual.

This reality raises an intriguing question: Would it matter to you if a DJ was merely pressing play instead of curating a live set? As long as the music resonates, would the role of technology be a concern?

Generative AI is at the forefront of this conversation. A highlight of that night was observing our special guest, Andy Cato from Groove Armada, skillfully blend tracks. But it does make one ponder: how would my perception change if the DJ wasn’t fully engaged, but rather relying on technology?

This reflection ties into a broader discussion about our appreciation for art and the creators behind it, whether it's a painting, a song, or a book. The music service Deezer has reported that 44% of the tracks uploaded to its platform are generated by AI. However, its research also indicates that 97% of listeners struggle to distinguish AI-generated music from that created by humans. Yet, more than half of the surveyed individuals expressed a desire for human involvement in artistic creation.

Daniel Susskind, an economics professor at King's College London, emphasizes the importance we place on the human touch in art. He recalls an instance where an accountant suggested clients appreciate the personal connection in their services, to which he countered that clients primarily seek accuracy. This differentiates art, he argues; viewers admire not only the artistry of the Sistine Chapel but also the fact that it was conceived by a human being capable of dreaming and creating.

Susskind remarks that our fascination often lies not just in the final product, but in recognizing that a person, like us, facilitated its creation. This admiration may not extend to AI, yet as technology becomes more embedded in art, some believe it will enhance the value placed on human-created works.

Kyle Chayka, a technology journalist with The New Yorker, observes that AI-generated content is often seen as "generic and banal," prompting readers to increasingly value personal, imperfect writing. This trend extends to art and design as well, with creatives striving for uniqueness to stand out against easily accessible AI-generated works.

In response to the rise of AI-produced content, some academics are looking to establish a universal symbol to signify "human-made" creations, reminiscent of the "Fairtrade" label. This distinction could become increasingly important as society navigates these technological advances.

Philosophy professor C Thi Nguyen posits that our core values can often be uncovered by interrogating our motivations. If human engagement remains significant to our values, it would stand to reason that it must remain integral to artistic creation.

Author John Lanchester expresses optimism that the uniqueness of human contributions will continue to hold considerable value. He echoes the sentiment of a 'human premium' that emerges when commonplace, commodified items are overshadowed by those that retain a personal touch.

Nonetheless, the rapid increase in AI-produced material raises concerns about our ability to discern between human and AI contributions in art. For instance, Tilly Norwood, an AI-generated "actor," stirred controversy, prompting the Screen Actors Guild to express skepticism toward computer-generated performances absent of genuine human experience.

It seems unlikely that AI will replace actors entirely, but as technology evolves, we may become desensitized to its presence in creative spaces. Furthermore, long before AI became prevalent, we had already allowed technology to shape our cultural consumption patterns. Nowadays, culture often arrives at our screens, curated by algorithms predicting our tastes, reducing the role of human curators.

While this algorithmic approach may provide convenience, it often diminishes our engagement with more challenging, thought-provoking art forms. Chayka posits that relying on algorithms can lead to a less enriched cultural experience, as we might shy away from deeper, more impactful works in favor of easily digestible content.

Interestingly, there seems to be a growing appreciation for live, in-person events, such as concerts and festivals, as a counterbalance to our increasingly digital lives. Alex Mahon, CEO of Superstruct Entertainment, observes that individuals are increasingly seeking unpredictable and unique experiences that foster genuine connection.

As we navigate our choices regarding technology's role in the arts, it's clear that each person will need to reflect on what constitutes significance in human-made creations. The future may test our ability to discern the value of human agency in a world rapidly adapting to the capabilities of AI.

Loading comments...